The Honorable Steven P. Ruble issued a decision on November 15, 2011, following a bench trial, finding the City of Onamia was not responsible for an alleged unconstitutional taking of property stemming from a road improvement project. The City had authorized a developer to improve a road, provided it stayed within the established right-of-way. Unfortunately, the developer assumed there was a 66-foot right-of-way, when there was not. The landowner sued only the City seeking to compel the City to condemn the area of the encroachment. The Court found the City not liable for a taking where there was no intention to acquire the encroached upon area. Paul D. Reuvers and Jason J. Kuboushek defended the City of Onamia.